About CMCT
Consulting Services
Training Programs
India Practice
Technology Practice
University Practice
Health Care Practice
News & Events
Case Studies
Articles: Managing Change
Articles: Cross-Cultural Management
Articles: Doing Business with India
Site Map
Contact CMCT

CMCT Articles


Print Version

How Culture Affects Motivation
By Dr. Karine Schomer, President, CMCT

When high-tech employees and managers from India, the US and other cultural backgrounds are thrown together in the intense environment of Silicon Valley, they often bring with them divergent expectations about workplace success factors, rewards and career development as well as differences in motivational "wiring."

Understanding these differences and adapting appropriately can be a key strategy for managers and employees alike. Failure to do so can lead to costly misunderstandings.

Five major differences in the following areas create the greatest challenges: management styles, job security and compensation structures, career development, performance evaluation, and motivational strategies.

Management styles

American employees react well to a boss who is friendly and professional with them, treats them as equals, and expects them to be independent and self-motivated. Managers and employees do not expect the boss-subordinate relationship to be strongly hierarchical, or to be one of strongly committed personal loyalty: it is all about mutual respect. This can create a mismatch for employees from India, for whom a more quasi-paternal relationship is more the norm.

Job security and compensation structures

The US has been through a workplace revolution in which expectations of job security with a lifetime employer has been replaced by loyalty to one's career and the attempt to maximize one's earnings. This results in a common acceptance of modest a base salary but a high bonus-earning potential. A common complaint I have heard from Silicon Valley employers has been about the discomfort of their employees from India with such an arrangement, with a strong preference for security over higher-stake risk.

Career development

A very common American manager's question to an employee is: "What are your career plans?" This question, which embodies the mutual expectation that employees take independent responsibility for their professional advancement, runs counter to the expectations of work cultures in many other countries, including India, where the expectation is that it is the boss's responsibility to look out for and decide on an employee's future.

Performance evaluation

The performance evaluation process of US companies today is a major culture shock for employees and managers from elsewhere. Highly formalized, it is based on mutually agreed-upon goals, involves forthright discussion of strengths and weaknesses, and has a formal written sign-off. Elsewhere, there may be informally conducted reviews with mentoring counsel, or a pattern of reprimands. The cultural problems of adaptation on all sides are considerable: the American way seems confrontational and legalistic to others, Americans feel insecure with methods that have less clarity.

Motivational strategies

When it comes to motivation, no one strategy works for everyone - even within one culture. Across cultures, it's even more difficult. With Americans, a manager shouldn't expect much from appeals to duty, authority, company loyalty, group rewards or regular after-work socializing. Instead, he or she should emphasize opportunities for personal growth and monetary gain. With employees from India, personal loyalty, company prestige and appeal to authority can be effective, but above all, the manager should cultivate a certain "human touch" in relating to the needs of subordinates, as their guide and friend as well as their boss.

© 2001 Karine Schomer. All Rights Reserved. Originally published in Siliconindia, November 2000.


For more information, contact CMCT, write to info@cmct.net, or call 510-525-9222.

Home  |  About CMCT  |  Consulting Services  |  Training Programs
India Practice
  |  Technology Practice  |  University Practice   |  Health Care Practice
News & Events  |  Case Studies  |  Articles  |  Clients  |  Site Map  |  Contact CMCT

© 2002-2009 Change Management Consulting & Training, LLC. All Rights Reserved.